Case Law Developments within the Real Estate & Strata Sectors (Q3 2026)

Categories: Liability, General Industry Updates, Professional Indemnity15 min readPublished On: October 30, 2026

The period between 1 July and 30 September 2026 saw the commencement of the expanded anti-money laundering regime, changes to tenancy and strata administration, and further regulatory action against property agents. The cases considered below address authority to act for a scheme, common property obligations and the procedural requirements for pursuing or defending claims.

To read about the latest legislative and regulatory developments, visit our related article here, and see case law developments below.

New South Wales

John Goubran & Associates Pty Ltd v The Owners – Strata Plan 57150 [2026] NSWCA 188
The earlier decision in John Goubran & Associates Pty Ltd v The Owners – Strata Plan 57150 [2026] NSWDC 9 considered the 2025 amendment extending the limitation period under s 106(6) of the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW) from two years to six years. The District Court held that the amendment did not revive the plaintiff’s statutory claim, which had already become time-barred under the former two-year limit. Nevertheless, the plaintiff recovered damages for lost rental income in negligence.

Following a hearing on 31 August 2026, the Court of Appeal delivered its decision on 9 September 2026 in John Goubran & Associates Pty Ltd v The Owners – Strata Plan 57150 [2026] NSWCA 188. The appeal did not revisit the earlier findings regarding the limitation period or negligence. Instead, the plaintiff sought leave to appeal on the basis that the primary judge failed to address the plaintiff’s claim for repair costs and interest.

While the Court of Appeal accepted that those issues had not been expressly addressed at first instance, leave to appeal was ultimately refused, having regard to the limited amounts in dispute, the plaintiff’s failure to first seek correction of the judgment in the District Court under UCPR r 36.16, and difficulties associated with the repairs claim in light of the primary judge’s other findings.

Keay v The Owners – Strata Plan 3132 [2026] NSWSC 1150
This decision, published on 23 September 2026, involves errors when consolidating and registering a strata scheme’s by-laws. The plaintiff, Mr Keay, a lot owner in the strata scheme, held exclusive use and enjoyment rights to a car parking space and a storeroom under existing common property rights by-laws. When the by-laws were consolidated in 2017, parts of those by-laws were inadvertently omitted, resulting in the lot owner’s rights not being properly recorded in the registered consolidated by-laws.

The plaintiff commenced proceedings seeking declaratory relief confirming his entitlement to the parking space and storeroom, together with orders requiring correction of the strata records. Although the defendant did not dispute the errors, it argued that declaratory relief was unnecessary.

The Court rejected the defendant’s argument and held that the declarations were appropriate, noting they would declare the plaintiff’s rights definitively under the relevant by-laws and serve utility in resolving ongoing disputes. The Court further found that it had power under s138 of the Real Property Act 1900 (NSW) to make orders facilitating correction of the registered by-laws.

Victoria

Director of Consumer Affairs Victoria v White Ray (Oakleigh) Pty Ltd [2026] FCA 497
In the decision, the issue was whether White Ray (Oakleigh) Pty Ltd trading as Ray White (Oakleigh) (RWO), contravened the Australian Consumer Law (ACL) by advertising residential properties at prices substantially below both its expected sale prices and the prices ultimately achieved, and if so, what penalty was appropriate.

Facts:
On nine occasions between March 2022 and November 2023, RWO advertised residential properties at indicative prices substantially below their eventual sale prices. In most cases, the advertised prices were also substantially below the prices RWO internally expected the properties to achieve. Some discrepancies exceeded 30%.

RWO earned $204,367 in commissions from the nine sales, generating just over $70,000 in net profit. The Court noted that RWO was a small business, with annual revenue of approximately $4 million and a pre-tax profit of just over $215,000.

The parties agreed that the price representations were misleading or deceptive, false or misleading as to price.

The Court accepted that prospective purchasers were likely exposed to harm through false price expectations and the expenditure of unnecessary time and resources pursuing properties they may otherwise not have considered.

In considering the appropriateness of the total amount of the penalties to be imposed, the Court considered various mitigating and aggravating factors.

Conclusion:
The Court found that RWO had contravened the ACL by engaging in deliberate underquoting. The Court imposed pecuniary penalties totalling $600,000, payable in two instalments. The Court accepted the jointly proposed penalty as appropriate after considering the deliberateness of the conduct, its likely harm, RWO’s financial circumstances, remediation, cooperation and lack of prior contraventions.

Implications:
The decision reinforces the importance of ensuring advertised price guides are supported by the agency’s genuine expectations and contemporaneous records. Although inaccurate representations may give rise to private claims where resulting loss is established, this proceeding concerned regulatory penalties and did not determine negligence or award compensation to vendors or purchasers. For PI insurers, deliberate underquoting and the resulting penalties require separate assessment under the applicable exclusions and extensions; the judgment does not establish that such liabilities are insured.

Queensland

Huang v Body Corporate for the Dorchester CTS 10749 [2026] QCA 147
On 7 August 2026, the Queensland Court of Appeal considered the interaction between the Human Rights Act 2019 (Qld) (HRA) and adjudications conducted under the Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997 (Qld) (BCCM Act). The dispute arose after a body corporate rescinded an earlier approval for an unauthorised rooftop annex constructed within an exclusive-use area, following engineering reports identifying significant corrosion, water ingress and access issues affecting common property infrastructure.

Mr Huang argued on appeal that the relevant adjudicator infringed s 24 and s 58 of the HRA by restricting his rights in relation to property ownership.

The Court granted leave to appeal to consider the application of the HRA to body corporate adjudications. The appeal was ultimately dismissed.

The Court held that a BCCM adjudicator determining disputes between parties is acting as a tribunal exercising judicial power and therefore falls within the exclusion in s 9(4)(b) of the HRA. As a consequence, the adjudicator was not a “public entity” for the purposes of s 58 of the HRA when performing that adjudicative function. The Court also clarified that s 5(2)(a) of the HRA does not impose a freestanding obligation on courts and tribunals to directly apply every human right contained in Part 2 of the Act whenever they exercise judicial power. Rather, particular human rights must be relevant to the function being performed or the issues properly arising in the proceeding.

The decision is significant because it provides appellate guidance on the status of BCCM adjudicators under the HRA and clarifies the limited circumstances in which human rights arguments will directly arise in private body corporate disputes.

Lee v The Body Corporate for Solaya CTS 31654 and Bergamin [2026] QCATA 120
On 3 August 2026, the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) Appeal Tribunal refused leave to appeal and dismissed the application by lot owners challenging an adjudicator’s decision upholding a body corporate resolution authorising the installation of a security camera doorbell on common property and awarding costs against the applicants.

The appellants alleged that the motion was invalidly proposed, that the voting process at the AGM was defective and that the recorded voting outcome was inaccurate. They also challenged the adjudicator’s finding that their application was frivolous, vexatious, misconceived and without substance, and the resulting $2,000 costs order.

The Tribunal held that appeals from body corporate adjudicators under the Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997 (Qld) are limited to questions of law. Most of the appellants’ grounds sought to challenge factual findings and therefore did not disclose any appealable error. The Tribunal found no error in the adjudicator’s conclusion that the resolution was validly passed and that any alleged procedural irregularities in the voting process did not affect the outcome, as the evidence demonstrated that the majority of lot owners intended the motion to pass.

The Tribunal also upheld the costs order, confirming that an adjudicator may award costs under s 270(3) where an application is frivolous, vexatious, misconceived or without substance. In doing so, the Tribunal rejected arguments that procedural fairness required further submissions on costs or that the adjudicator was obliged to obtain additional evidence, including an audio recording of the meeting.

The decision reinforces that appeals to QCAT from BCCM adjudicators are confined to questions of law and are not an opportunity to re-litigate factual findings. On the facts, the alleged voting irregularities did not establish an appealable error; this does not mean that majority intention cures statutory non-compliance. Unmeritorious applications may also expose parties to adverse costs orders.

Body Corporate for Villas Mermaid CTS 9057 v Mainmark Ground Engineering (Qld) Pty Ltd [2026] QCAT 246
The Body Corporate (the applicant) was self-represented by Ms Bridget Rodham. Mainmark Ground Engineering (the respondent) was represented by lawyers. The claim was for just over $145k plus interest arising from incomplete or defective work (alleged defects in soil stabilisation works by the respondent) and consequential physical damage to a building. The decision was delivered on 27 May 2026 by QCAT.

The Tribunal dismissed the applicant’s claim. Firstly, pursuant to s 312 of the Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997 (Qld) (BCCM Act) the applicant was required to have authority by reason of a “special resolution” passed by body corporate members, which it had not obtained. Secondly, this meant the jurisdiction of the Tribunal had not been engaged.

Having found that the proceeding lacked the required authorisation, the Tribunal made observations about jurisdiction. It did not conclusively determine whether the soil stabilisation works constituted building work or domestic building work. However, it considered that the standalone works might fall outside the statutory definition of building work and, if classified as commercial building work, the claim could not proceed as a major commercial building dispute without the contractor’s consent to the jurisdiction of QCAT.

This decision is an important reminder of when a party ought to consider obtaining legal representation. Member Taylor observed “[37] …one of the objects of the QCAT Act is to have the Tribunal deal with matters in a way that is accessible, fair, just, economical, informal, and quick; …” and “[38] … Where a party presents a case to this Tribunal which is complicated in terms of the relevant and applicable law, it is such a case that should call for legal representation.” and “[39]…When a party chooses to conduct its case as a self-represented litigant it can be to their peril. This is particularly so in circumstances where they embark on their case and/or present it without having an adequate understanding of the relevant law and legal principles that arise within it, and at least have taken some legal advice about it and act in accordance with that advice…”.
The decision also highlights questions of authority to commence proceedings and the chosen jurisdiction.

Western Australia

Zhao v The Owners of 5 Wimbledon Street Beckenham Strata Scheme 40695 [2026] WASC 328
Dong Hua Zhao, the first appellant, and Shao Juan Fan, the second appellant, were the registered proprietors of Lot 2 (with a lot entitlement of 46/100) on Strata Plan 40695 . This is a two lot scheme. Ms Packer was the registered proprietor of Lot 1 (with a lot entitlement of 54/100). The appellants initial application to the State Administrative Tribunal (SAT) sought orders for an auditor of the accounts and of all contracts.

On 17 August 2026, Bydder J of the Supreme Court of Western Australia allowed an appeal from the SAT concerning governance and decision-making within a two-lot strata scheme.
The Court held that a 2020 ordinary resolution authorising the strata council to enter into and execute contracts did not authorise a single council member to execute documents on behalf of the strata company.
Under s 118 of the Strata Titles Act 1985 (WA), authority granted to “members of the council acting jointly” is distinct from authority granted to an individual council member. The owner of Lot 1 was not authorised to execute strata management agreements or a legal costs agreement on behalf of the strata company merely because she held the majority of the scheme’s unit entitlements.

The Court emphasised that a majority unit entitlement affects the outcome of certain votes where voting by unit entitlement is available, but does not itself confer authority to execute documents on behalf of a strata company.

In relation to voting rights, the Court distinguished between an owner’s entitlement to vote on ordinary resolutions and eligibility to serve on the strata council. Even if the appellants had been “unfinancial” (that is, money was owed by the lot owner), that would only have affected their ability to vote on ordinary resolutions. It would not have prevented a nominated co-owner from serving on the council or being authorised to execute documents on behalf of the strata company.

The Court held the appellants were not “unfinancial” for the purposes of the Act because the strata company, as a two-lot scheme, was not authorised to establish an administrative fund in the absence of a by-law requiring one. Consequently, the administrative levies relied upon by the strata company were not recoverable under the Act and could not deprive the appellants of voting rights.

The Court found that SAT could not retrospectively authorise the establishment of an administrative fund through its general scheme – dispute powers under Pt 13 of the Act. Section 140 provides a specific mechanism under which a member may apply for an order requiring a two-lot strata company to perform designated functions. The Court held s 140 covers the field in relation to those matters and could not be circumvented by broader remedial powers under ss 199 and 200.

The appeal was allowed. SAT’s declarations and orders were set aside. The matter was remitted to a differently constituted Tribunal for reconsideration.

The decision highlights the authority of lot owners, and confirms that being “unfinancial” does not mean a lot owner’s losing its rights.

Godwin v Keet [2026] WASC 105
The appellant, Lauraine Godwin, is an occupier of one of 20 lots in the Waterfront Apartments, and is also the attorney for the owner of that lot pursuant to an enduring power of attorney. The respondent is the managing director of Strata Asset Services, the scheme’s strata manager.

On 2 April 2026, Lundberg J of the Supreme Court of Western Australia refused leave to appeal from the decisions of the State Administrative Tribunal concerning the management of the Waterfront Apartments strata scheme and the operation of strata management agreements.

The appellant contended that strata management agreements entered into in 2021 and 2023 were invalid or had been terminated due to alleged breaches of the Strata Titles Act 1985 (WA) and scheme by-laws. The Court upheld the Tribunal’s conclusion that the 2023 strata management agreement remained in force. In doing so, the Court emphasised that termination under s 151 of the Strata Titles Act 1985 (WA) was not automatic upon an alleged breach. The attempted termination failed because the extraordinary general meeting and council meeting relied upon to authorise termination were found to be invalid, and the show-cause notice and termination notice were themselves defective, having been issued simultaneously rather than in the sequential manner required by the Act and failing to comply with the statutory requirements governing termination.

While the Tribunal rejected the appellant’s challenge to the continued operation of the 2023 strata management agreement (the 2021 agreement had expired on 19 June 2023), it also identified significant governance deficiencies within the scheme. It found that the council of owners was not validly constituted following certain annual general meetings and that an extraordinary general meeting held in January 2024, together with resolutions passed at that meeting, was invalid. To address those governance failures, the Tribunal ordered that a fresh general meeting be convened, a new council elected, and decisions made during periods when the council was improperly constituted be reviewed and either confirmed or set aside.

The decision highlights the importance of adhering to the statutory procedures governing both strata management contract termination and strata company governance under the Strata Titles Act 1985 (WA). It also demonstrates that although the strata manager successfully resisted the termination challenge, the Tribunal nevertheless identified governance irregularities requiring corrective action.

Perth Day Hospital Pty Ltd v Fitness Cartel Western Australia Pty Ltd & Ors (No 3) [2026] WASC 314
The Plaintiff operated a private day hospital, performing pain-management and endoscopy procedures, in a commercial strata complex adjoining and partly beneath a 24-hour gymnasium operated by the Third Defendant, Fitness Cartel Osborne Park Pty Ltd (the Gym). The Plaintiff commenced treating patients on 3 June 2026.

The First Defendant, Fitness Cartel Western Australia Pty Ltd, was the franchisor, while the Second Defendant, PHR Holdings (WA) Pty Ltd, owned the gym premises. Although the trial focused on the Third Defendant as the gym operator, the Court considered the Defendants’ conduct collectively because they did not differentiate their respective roles or conduct.

It was alleged that noise and vibration from the weightlifting and high-intensity training conducted at the Gym substantially interfered with the Plaintiff’s medical procedures. Therefore, the Plaintiff sought a permanent injunction against the Defendants. No damages were claimed.

Although the interference before June 2026 was substantial and unreasonable when assessed against ordinary office use, the Court held that the Plaintiff’s delicate procedures constituted a hypersensitive rather than ordinary use of the premises. By contrast, operating a gym was a common and ordinary use within the industrial locality and the building’s history.

The Defendants submitted that they had implemented measures to mitigate the impact of gym activities, including reducing music volume, modifying flooring and discouraging disruptive member behaviour. Despite this, the Plaintiff proceeded with a claim for private nuisance seeking a permanent injunction.

The Court found that the Defendants’ measures made the gym’s activities “conveniently done” by June 2026 and reduced any subsequent or ongoing interference to an insubstantial level.

Applying the principle of reciprocity and balancing the parties’ competing uses of the commercial building, the Court found that permanently restricting the gym’s operations was unjustified. The Plaintiff’s action was thus dismissed and the interlocutory injunction granted on 2 June 2026 was also dissolved. As at the time of this update, the case was marked as “Pending Appeal”.

Northern Territory

No relevant decisions were identified for the reporting period.

Key contacts

Courtney Steele, Principal

Mario Raciti, Partner

Iona Sjahadi, Partner

Natasha Fiodoroff, Special Counsel

 

Disclaimer: This article is intended for informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal advice. For any legal advice please contact us.

Related articles